Local. Trusted. Here for You.
About Our Team
Our Mission
Guided by Integrity, Driven by Service
At Agape Insurance Group, our mission is to serve with a deep, authentic care rooted in Agape—the selfless, unconditional love described in the Bible. We believe every individual deserves protection for what they hold dear, and we approach each client with warmth, respect, and a commitment to understanding their unique needs. With a focus on providing guidance and compassionate support, we strive to bring peace of mind and trust to all who walk through our doors.
Our purpose is simple: to deliver insurance that truly serves you, backed by a love for people and a commitment to always act in your best interests.
“For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.”
– Romans 5:7-8
Your Dedicated Insurance Experts
Meet The Team
Joe Aiello
Agency Owner
Joe is the owner of Agape Insurance Group and has been an insurance agent since 2011. He holds a Bachelors of Arts from Western Carolina University in Middle School Math and Social Studies education. While he no longer teaches at the middle school level, he tries each day to use his teaching degree by educating clients and helping them understand and manage their everyday risks.
Joe is married to his wife, Sandra, and lives in Wake Forest. He has three children. When he’s not working, he loves to read, cheer on his home town Chicago sports teams, and play pickleball.
Judith Bolton
Customer Service Manager
Judith came to Agape Insurance in 2022 and manages the day the day customer service needs of the agency. She has over 20 years of experience in the insurance industry and enjoys building relationships with the clients and giving them quality service. She holds a property and casualty and life license. Her free time is spent with family and friends on the lake.
She enjoys reading, doing crafts and volunteering with the Civitans and Miracle League of Franklin County.
Adam Behr
Sales
Adam joined Agape Insurance Group in 2023 and is licensed in New Jersey and North Carolina. His previous experience teaching physics helps him breakdown complicated insurance ideas into manageable discussions. Adam prides himself in providing a clear, concise, and educational approach to risk management. By utilizing his resources and experience he can paint a holistic view of his clients’ risk management program and provide solutions not typically offered by other insurance agencies.
Adam’s educational credentials include a Bachelors of Science in Physics from Seton Hall University and a Master of Arts in Teaching from The College of New Jersey. Adam resides in Smithfield, North Carolina with his wife and two dogs.
Josh Lafoon
Customer Service
Josh joined our team in 2024 as a licensed insurance professional specializing in Property, Casualty, Health, and Life Insurance for North Carolina. He brings 16 years of experience in financial services and holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Science from North Carolina State University. With a technical and analytical approach, Josh efficiently manages policy processes, guiding clients from Pending to Active with precision.
Josh lives in Wake Forest with his wife and son—and his identical twin brother, who may or may not have an "evil" side. Outside of work, he enjoys building train tracks with his son and playing board games and PC games.
ENDORSED BY Dave
Ramsey Trusted Providers
As a RamseyTrusted provider, we are proud to be recommended by personal finance expert Dave Ramsey. This endorsement reflects our dedication to helping clients make smart financial decisions through responsible, reliable insurance options. It’s a mark of trust, integrity, and a commitment to always put our clients first.
Real Feedback from Our Valued Clients
Testimonials
Elizabeth Tong
I found Adam Behr courteous and got back to me very quickly. Because of a family situation, I had less than 2 weeks to look for a new policy or would need to stay with the old carrier. The old carrier increased my policy by over $1,000 annually. Adam found a new insurance company for me with about $1,000 in savings annually. Adam was also very patient explaning the coverage.
Bruce Birbeck
Thanks Joe:
As an ex-Insurance agent, myself I appreciate a job, not only done well, but without a strong sales overtone. You access my needs.
Your office staff has kept me well informed during every transaction.
Bruce
Stanley Herring
Joe and his team have always been there when I needed them. They even reached out before my renewal period to see if they could save me money. In fact, they did, saving me almost 10% on my homeowners policy. Wonderful folks to work with!
Susan Winter
Very satisfied with the service. So easy to work with and answered all my questions.
Colin Emerson
Joe and his team are professional, straightforward, and prompt. They present a range of options and keep us updated on changes in regulations and policies. Highly recommend!
Susan Winn
I had an auto claim and everything went so smoothly. Highly recommend Joe and his team.
Robert MacRae
Joe Aiello and his staff at Agape have been my exclusive insurance provider for all needs for several years.
Their attention to having risk needs met through discussions and policy formation is outstanding.
Moreover, in those unfortunate situations when unwanted events happen and coverage needs to be called upon, their true personal service is there every step of the way assuring that your life is minimally intrupted and returned to normal expeditiously.
Ed Boiar
Joe and his team are outstanding. They do the hard work so it's easier for their customers.
Angela Lombardi
Joe has always been extremely professional, kind and helpful. Thank you, Agape!
Ashik Pavagadhi
Agape Ins. Group has serviced my insurance needs for the last 3 years with exceptional service! Thank you Joe for always proactively managing my policies.
Ryan Warwick
Highly recommend. I've been with Joe and team for years now. They helped me navigate my policies when I switched homes and when I had to add some extra vehicles to my policy. They do a great job of getting the best value for my policies and our also open to shop for better rates during renewals. Joe and Judith are a great Team!! Very responsive and easy to work with. Especially through some stressful claim processes, they always there for support and guidance.
Derek Baker
Really easy process from start to finish. I enjoy working with Adam - he was very patient and engaged throughout the process, addressing all of my questions, concerns, and highlighting issues I had not considered. This is a great team all around and I look forward to working with them for years to come.
Capital Coin & Jewelry LLC
My business has been with Joe/Agape Insurance going on 5years now. Very pleased with the rates and level of service. Thank you Joe
John Reinhard
Jake from Statefarm ain't got nothing on Joe from Agape! Has made my life easy.
Mariella Arroba
I highly recommend Agape Insurance Group! Joe and his team are absolutely fantastic. They are not only highly knowledgeable but also incredibly responsive and attentive to all my insurance needs. Their expertise and professionalism made the entire process seamless and reassuring. I truly appreciate their dedication and would trust them with any insurance-related matter without hesitation. Thank you, Agape Insurance Group, for your exceptional service and expertise!
Debbie Walker
I received amazing support and service from Joe. He provided a quick quote for home and auto insurance that saved us a TON of money. 5 Stars for Agape! Thanks Joe😊
Mary Stoll
Responsive, knowledgeable, friendly, prompt with service.
Bonnie Cassone
I made a phone call to Joe and was pleasantly surprised by how much money I was able to save plus got additional coverage! Joe made the transition from my prior insurance company so easy! I would highly recommend giving him a call.
Holly Morgan
Joe is absolutely great. He has helped us every step of the way in the process of insuring our home and we will defiantly be switching all of our insurance needs to him!
Kirk McWhorter
I have worked with Joe Aiello and Agape for a few years now, insuring my primary home, investment properties and my car. Joe always recommends the right level of coverage, finds great rates and helps me navigate changes in my business that affect insurance coverage. He is knowledgeable, responsive and great to work with!
Michael Manchester
I started using Joe Aiello as my insurance argent for my car insurance a little over a ear ago. When I became a mortgage loan originator I needed someone that I trusted to refer my mortgage clients to. Joe has been very quick at calling or e mailing the clients that I have referred to him. Joe has been able to find great home owners insurance programs for my clients.
Barbara Fitzgerald
Great follow through on issues and always working for the benefit of the customer.
Janet Mele
Joe Aiello was very knowledgeable and patient in helping me to decide the insurance coverage for auto, house, and umbrella.
Philip Carter
Joe Aiello and his team welcomed me to his network warmly and took care of all of my needs quickly and professionally. Thanks Joe!
Megan S
I have been with Joe for years and he is always available and very helpful! He goes out of his way to make sure you have the best plan at the best price. I would recommend Agape 100%.
David Parsons
This is an insurance company that knows what the word service means. Great and timely service.
Jill Lewis
Wonderful agency! I appreciate Joe's knowledge, kindness and support of the industry!
Shao Dong Wang
Joe is fantastic. He has been helping us in past 4 years, always providing timely feedback when we have questions and finding us the policy that fits us the best.
Keyla Springs
Joe and his team are the best! They are quick to respond, honest, and overall have you best interest at heart. I wish I could give them 10 stars!
Mary Resseguie
Joe Aiello is a consummate professional. Highly responsive and knowledgeable about the insurance industry and related industries, such as real estate. Joe is also proactive about staying on top of the best options for my family. I give Agape Insurance Group and Joe Aiello my highest recommendation.
Leslie Zatyko
I recently moved to NC and needed my health insurance taken care of. Joe was amazing and incredibly helpful in every way. He got my policy in place right away. I turned to Agape again a few weeks later, to get the insurance policy on my home and business - once again, the policy was in place right away! Then I realized my auto policy needed to get transferred and once again Agape helped me get my policy in place and explained the differences in NC coverages vs. CA. The Agape Team are so professional, warm, and caring. They know their stuff and are very easy to work with....I highly recommend them!
Earl Greene
I've been a client of the Agape Insurance Group for a number of years and my experience with them has been great. They responded quickly when I had a claim and they made that process go very smoothly. That's what I look for in an insurance company.
Mike Kirsch
Joe did a great job earning my business. It was able to come in less than I was paying with Allstate.
patricia siebert
Swift move from another company appreciate judith Bolton and her expertise thank you
Kyle
Easy access to agent and information. Friendly and informative.
John Rankin
Joe is very outgoing and very patient. Whenever I have questions or when things are unclear, he takes time to connect and answer questions and ensure that details are clearly communicated. He goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction.
Robert Gavin
Joe and his team have been extremely professional, down-to-earth and honest with their advice. I'm so glad I was able to connect and use their services over the last 4 years.
lawrence rosenthal
Very happy with Agape Insurance! Joe is a wonderful person to work with. Happy to recommend Agape!
Todd O'Neill
Joe is an amazing person and always looks out for his clients’ best interests. He is dependable and responsive to all calls whether emergent or not. I would trust and recommend Joe for any insurance need.
Brian Barton
I have used other insurance companies for my personal and business insurance needs, but never with the same value and customer service Agape has given us. They have always been there for me when I need assistance and I love it!
Gilles Godin
Two reasons why five stars. The first is based on service provided to me personally. I am more than satisfied. The second reason validates the first. People I referred feel the same.
Jacky Philpotts
I have been a client of Joe Aiello’s for three years since I moved to NC. I have been very pleased with his professionalism and compassion. He wrote me an auto policy that protected me in an accident that totaled my car.
I highly recommend Joe and Agape for all your insurance requirements.
Bob Drake
A friend referred my wife and I to the Agape Insurance Group when we first moved to NC three years ago. We have since had insurance for our home and autos through Agape. We have consistently been impressed with Joe Aiello's thoroughness in accessing our coverage needs and his presentation of coverage options. Joe's knowledge base is exceptional. He and his staff are remarkably timely in responding to inquiries and requests. For the same reasons that the group was recommended to us, we would have no hesitation in highly recommending Agape to others.
Caleb Piper
I have homeowners, auto, umbrella, life, and commercial insurance with Agape. Joe provided me with top tier insurance at an unbeatable price. Also, Joe is super knowledgeable and provides A+ customer service. I couldn't be more happy!
Colin Bryan
Joe Aiello was extremely knowledgeable and helped guide me through the process of selecting home and auto policies that gave me the best coverage at competitive rates. I learned a lot during my conversations with Joe and I know that I can go to him any time to get answers to my questions. I would highly recommend using Joe and Agape for any and all insurance needs!
Elizabeth Schneider
Joe and his team are amazing. So on top of everything and they WILL get you the best rate. If anything goes wrong, they are on it. Amazing customer service, great agency!
Wendy Kowalczyk
attentive and thorough. Joe is very honest.
Robert Berghorn, Jr.
Joe and his team are really efficient and effective at finding the best rates for you and your family. We recently started working with them as we were buying our first home. They have been top notch all the way through the process and really took the time to answer any and all questions. My wife and I look forward to continuing to work with them as we continue grow as a family in our new home
H Tarkington
Saved me about $350 a year on auto and almost $1,000 a year on homeowners. Very easy to work with, prompt service so far.
Kaleb Bishop
Joe was absolutely amazing to work with. My wife and I are both young and needed lots of help getting insurance setup after moving to NC. Joe went above and beyond and walked us through everything step by step (Even non insurance stuff like changing residency). I will absolutely be calling again when we have more insurance needs and I highly recommend them to everyone.
Cari Sch
I have had Joe as our insurance broker for years for our personal and business needs. He has always been available, answers all our questions, he is very perfectional, and looks after our family as if I am the only customer. He is very knowledgeable and someone you can trust. I have and will continue to recommend him to all of my family and friends. Thank you, Joe, for such an outstanding service!!!
Tristan Cooper
Working with Joe and Agape Insurance Group through my latest auto accident claim was a breeze. Quick responses and follow-ups. Highly recommended.
Isaac Orndorff
Joe was very focused on making sure I got the best deal possible for my family. He was able to raise my premium and also lower the cost of both car and renters insurance. I am very happy I was able to work with them!
Matt Watts
Joe and the team do a fantastic job at getting us the best rates on auto and home insurance. They also are super responsive and have great customer service. Highly recommend 👍
Sarah Denty
I was referred to Agape to assist with my ever increasing auto insurance rates. Joe was fast, efficient and super helpful! Answering all my questions along the way and making the process of changing insurance carriers easy and saving me a bunch along the way! Thank you!!
Jeremy Tarney
Joe's done a great job helping a new homeowner figure out the ins and outs of insurance. Couldn't have done it without you guys, thanks!
Benjamin Radey
Joe has been my agent for years and he's never hesitated to give me personal attention, make sure I fully understood my policies, and make sure all of my questions were answered. He's a true professional and has earned easily earned my 5-star review. Thanks Joe!
Karen Gibbons
Joe is fabulous to work with. He is very knowledgeable about insurance and takes the time to work with you.
Sarah Khuwaja
Joe is incredibly patient and knowledgeable about all things related to insurance. Throughout a long home buying process, we could always rely on him to be communicative and honestly assess our specific needs. Joe’s most impressive quality is his willingness to go above and beyond for his clients. We will definitely work with him again in the future!
Rod Chesnutt
Joe lives by the credo established by the name Agape. He truly cares, on a personal level, about each and every client/customer as if they were his own family. As for responsive, we were buying a new truck and he had us insured before the purchase papers were done! The salesperson was thoroughly impressed, as were we. In the insurance world, Joe is a standout!
Kristy Cook
Joe cares greatly for his clients and goes above and beyond for them to make sure they have the insurance they need to keep them protected!
Ryan Harradine
A colleague introduced me to Joe, who was extremely helpful in answering questions I was having about my old policy, even before I switched my coverage over to his agency. He gets to know you before discussing too many details/numbers, so he knows which ones are actually important to you. He is very patient and cognizant of people's time. The personal touch his agency provides really is so much better than the online-only agency I switched from.
Hussein Ahmad
The team at Agape has been fantastic to work with. They offer the best prices and have always been incredibly responsive. Thanks Joe and Judith!
Justin Pampuch
Adam is amazing. He explained every question I had and was very friendly. He made switching easy.
Linda Clough
I've never met an insurance agent quite like Joe. He is EXTREMELY knowledgeable about insurance and explains everything. I felt comfortable right from the start that he was different from the rest. We have been very satisfied with Joe and highly recommend him for insurance.
Bedel Saintange
If you're looking to save the actual savings advertised for switching, look no further. I recommend Agape Insurance group for all of your insurance needs.
Marie O Soriano
Joe has always been very prompt with responses and attentive to detail, I have been working with him for years and cannot recommend him enough.
Cindi Whiteside
Joseph was great to work with, and we were so pleased when we found out we could get more insurance coverage from a highly reputable company for substantially less than we had been paying our former insurance company for decades. I only wish we would have checked it out sooner! I highly recommend this company!
Greg Egan
Agape Insurance is so easy to work with! Joe is professional, responds quickly and always has my best interest as top priority. He goes the extra mile to make sure I get exactly the type of coverage I need! Highly Recommend!
Duct, Duct Pro!
Love working with Joe. Very responsive and thorough. He has done a great job at educating my clients about their homeowner’s policies too.
John Sweeney
What a fantastic experience with Joe and his team! Not only was the service top-notch, but the savings was even better! Please let Joe take a look at your policies. You won’t regret the chance.
Vince Rapp
Great team. For 20+ years, we shopped the "big names" as frequently advertised on TV, they were all more expensive and delivered service via a the "1-800 auto prompt, we will be right with you" process. It made my BP go up every time I had to deal with them. My son (in college) recently got small motorcycle, but bigger than a scooter. He needed "real" insurance and a license. Joe at Agape made several helpful suggestions which made the process smooth. Same thing happened when I sold my old SUV. They have earned our business and its nice to do it with a local service provider.
Carlton Eades
When I had questions about my policy, Joe Aiello was quick to respond and very knowledgeable. He worked to ensure that I had an insurance plan that fit my needs (and budget!). Definitely recommend Agape Insurance.
Barb Fitzgerald
Agape has always been a professional, friendly and reliable Insurance company for us. Always helpful!
Alex H
Joe is professional, experienced, courteous, and knowledgeable. We completed both auto and home insurance with Joe over the phone and by e-mail communications without any issues. No need to drive to his office. It was so efficient!
We are very pleased with insurance coverage and affordability of both auto and home insurance!
Candy Sugarman
I had been dreading changing health insurance, but Joe was great. The process was painless, quick, and efficient. I highly recommend Agape for your insurance needs.
Tracy Holt
I have gotten insurance from Joe for over 8 years, and before he started Agape Insurance. He's given me great service the entire time. Highly recommended.
udit ruia
Joe and his team is providing good, honest and transparent service. He is running a trustworthy shop.
Anthony S. Torres
I'd been talking with Joe for a while about insurance. He's given out great free advice to people, but I never got around to getting a quote thinking there was no need Well, that was just dumb of me. My renewal came around earlier this year and I finally said, hey, let's see if there's a difference. It was huge!
I had my home, auto, umbrella and my business insurance all quoted by Joe, and in the end I got the same, if not better in for most, and saved around $2500 per year! I should not have held off. Joe ran through everything with me, has followed up, and I just am in awe how he really makes sure everyone understand what they have and what they don't. He's honest and will let you know if what you have is good or not, no pressure to switch, so there's no reason to not get a quote. Thanks again, Joe.
Avni Gupta
Great insurance, right price, very responsive and guided us well!
Michelle Pro
It was great working with an agent that took personal care of our needs. I feel like it would be easy to reach out if I have any future needs. No annoying phone trees!
Ashley Lane
Agape Insurance has been great to work with! I had a situation recently that required a quick response outside of regular working hours, and Joe came through for me! He was quick to respond and is always polite, professional, and more than willing to help! I have worked with Joe for many years now and cannot recommend him/Agape enough for your insurance needs! It is comforting to be known as a person instead of just being another customer through the large insurance companies. You will not be disappointed with Agape’s services. 10/10 recommend!
Richard Thorsen
We are new to this agency. They provided our home, auto and umbrella coverage with Erie with better coverage and lower cost. Very proactive customer service. You can tell they are focused on our best interest. Highly recommend this agency. Also looking forward to a review of my medicare supplement plan in October.
Ryan Pauls
My wife and I recently realized we were over paying on home and auto. Joe took the time to find us better options and thoroughly went through said options to save us money. I would recommend giving Joe a call to see what he can do for you!
Amanda Chilton
Working with Adam at agape has been an amazing experience. He has been incredibly responsive and helped make sure I had the best possible price and coverage. He and Judith helped us navigate a very stressful claim with ease. I can't recommend Agape enough
Ruijuan Xu
Joe has been a great home insurance agent. He is knowledgeable, patient and responsive. He always responds to our questions quickly and provides immediate help to us. I would highly recommend him to other homeowners.
Davis Holt
I have worked with Joe Aiello for over 5 years as our exclusive insurance partner. Not only does Joe service all of my personal and business insurance needs but we have also recommended him to hundreds of clients over the years. Joe is extremely responsive, caring, and most importantly, he educates his clients on what they are buying. Joe does not sell you the best product for Joe, he explains what you need, why you need it and the benefits of having it. He always has your best interest at heart. Highly recommend Joe and team.
Patrick Williford
Joe is extremely knowledgeable when it comes to property and casualty insurance (he handles our vehicle and home policies). We came from one of the larger carriers because we thought we could get the best price from them. After interviewing several agencies Joe and Agape not only got us the most competitive rates, but great coverage and expert advice in a complicated industry.
Joe and Agape are one of the rare businesses where you get a great price AND great service. You will not regret having him take a look at your insurance needs.
Rakhi Nanwani
Both Joe and Adam were super easy to work with and provided me with a competitive rate, that made my decision to move the policy under their care very easy.
Cory Walter
Nothing but A+ service, I’ve been with Joe for years. He takes care of all my personal insurance and my business insurance.
TOP TIER!!!!
Thanks!
Tiago Mendes
Easy to communicate with, Joe cares about his customers
Christopher Bawden
Responses are very quick and makes dealing with our insurance easy!
Kuladeep Nadiminti
Wonderful company!! I definitely recommend Joe Aiello!! He’s been awesome at finding the best coverage for me regarding home and auto insurances!
He was able to provide good suggestions regarding the home and auto insurance coverages.
Joe Aiello is a professional and a pleasure to deal with.
Always has the answers for me and is quick to respond to my emails and phone calls.
Sherry Levine
I have been working with Joe Aiello for nearly 7 years now. He will always do what is in your best interest and make sure to listen to your needs. He also has provided recommendations to assist in getting work done. I very highly recommend Joe and Agape!!
Adriana Suarez
Joe took care of finding the best possible insurance rate for what I was looking for. He was very thorough in explaining exactly what the policy would entail and made sure to answer all my questions along the process. Plus, he is super responsive and easy to reach! If you have any insurance related questions or are interested in seeing if you could possibly save some money on your premium, I would highly recommended talking to Joe!!
Kelli Harrison
Agape was recommended from a friend when we were looking to compare insurance rates. Adam and Joe were very responsive and showed me great options and walked through them all as well as answering my questions. The transition to the new insurance company was incredibly smooth.
jackie cross
Agape Insurance is honest, friendly and professional. I am very pleased with every service they have provide and have referred them to my friends and associates.
Ben Dillon
I haven't had a local agent in years, it was nice to have one person to talk to. Joe was great helping me get set up for insurance for our new home and bundling autos. He kept us up to date with everything and made sure everything was in order. Highly recommend!
richard slater
We were so impressed with the insurance knowledge and guidance that Joe Aiello gave us during our office visit. We got the coverage we needed at a reasonable cost with friendly service. Great!
Catilyn Mitchell
Working with Joe is so very easy and cost effective. He is always following up with us and making sure we save the most money and get the best deal!
Nora Rochelle
My representative's professionalism and attentiveness to my individual personal needs was greatly appreciated. Thank you
Nancy Lerner
What a great relief to find someone to help and manage my policies. Joe finds the best policies for me, keeps in touch and lets me know when anything changes. So happy that I can relax and not stress out so much.
Adam Morris
Joe and Agape are fantastic! He searches proactively every year to see if we can get less expensive or better coverage. I recently filed a claim with my car insurance company for a windshield, and Joe called me soon after to make sure everything was okay and see if I needed any help. I can't say enough good things about Joe and Agape!
Belinda Berling
Joe is the best insurance broker! Super responsive, very professional, and really works hard at finding his clients the best rates. He is also very knowledgeable and really helps you find the best insurance products for your situation. I’ve recommended him to family, and would recommend him to anyone shopping for insurance (even if you are not, you should call him because he will likely save you some money!)
Brooks Carter
Joe of Agape Insurance Group is a great and professional guy who really cares about his customers. He knows the products he sales and does not push things on people. He only puts his customers in products that they need and does not push products that he knows you do not need. Agape has all of my insurance products and I trust them completely.
Charley Crowe
Joe Aiello has set out on a mission to help as many people as possible with their insurance needs. He has the personality and the knowledge to help you get the most of what you want out of your insurance products.
Call Joe today and spend a few minutes with him to see if today isn't the day you start getting what you really pay for!
Justin Pierce
Very pleased with the Agape Insurance Group. Always super helpful and quick whenever I need anything.
Dolev Zaharony
We have several policies through Agape and we are really happy with their services and plans
Dawn Brenengen
Joe at Agape is quick and responsive, is always able to save me money on insuring my rentals, and is excellent to work with!
Ian Stevens
Joseph Aiello helped us with our home owners insurance. Very easy process.
Kelby Zeiger
Joe and his team did a great job helping me find the right home insurance that suited my needs. Amazing personalized service and always prompt communication. I highly recommend the Agape Insurance Group.
Terry Sabo
Not sure how long that we have been with Joe and his staff. They have always been accommodating when we had a question or concern with insurance. We would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs
Susan Carpenter
By far, the best customer service I have ever experienced with insurance. The service started with a "no pressure " comparison of quotes between my pre-existing insurances and numerous other companies. Because Agape is an independent broker, it was like having a personal shopper checking all the comparisons AND making sure that I had the proper coverage for my needs. Whenever I have a question, they are only a phone call away!
Joel Simpson
Adam has been amazing to work with!!! He was informative, gave advise, met me multiple times to make sure me and my company had everything I needed. I highly recommend Agape insurance Group. I have switched to them for all of my insurance needs.
Brandon Singleton
it was an easy and cost effective solution to my insurance needs.
John O'Connor
You made our transition from USAA very easy and provided equivalent levels of coverage at a much more reasonable premium cost. Our first time using an agency and Joe and Judith have been very helpful during our transition. Thanks for all your help, John O'Connor
Diana Kelley
Joe Aiello has been my insurance agent for my home, vehicles and life since 2018 and I highly recommend his office! It is comforting to have a helpful agent who is very reliable and cares about his service. He is always super responsive by email and phone, no matter how small the inquiry.
Oscar Vivtor
Friendly local agents that are very happy to serve. I recommend this place to all my friends and family! Happy customer 🫡
Andrew Darragh
Joe took care of all our insurance needs and found really good deals! It is really nice to have someone doing all that legwork for us. It’s a real time saver!
Brian Meyers
If you want an agent who looks out for you and your family Joe Aiello and Agape insurance is for you . I recommend him to friends all the time.
Dan Beesmer
Joe was great to work with.
Tiffany Quinnette
They are very helpful, answer the phone and really looknout for the customer .
Stephanie Saville
Joe was great to work with! We were looking into changing our homeowners and auto insurance, and I happened to come across a recommendation for Agape Insurance in someone else's post when on my Nextdoor account. He certainly lived up to the wonderful reviews on Google as well when I did some further research. He was knowledgeable, friendly and responded to email and voicemail quickly. Judith, his Customer Service Agent, was also very helpful and a pleasure to speak with. Agape ended up saving us money on both types of insurance, and we will absolutely recommend them and will work with them again in the future!
Joseph Gerber
Joe Aiello helped my wife and me get a great set of insurance policies for good savings. He was great at counseling on recommended coverage, explaining the system and policies and processes. Never felt undue pressure to purchase something we didn't need. Also extremely responsive. A great agent, the best kind of salesperson, 5/5 would highly recommend!
Caleb Fordham
Agape Insurance Group is the best thing since sliced bread as far as dealing with Home Insurance/Car Insurance/ and what not. They've definitely given us the best deal available in the market on pricing and quality while also providing excellent customer service. Our house flooded due to a broken washing machine, and Joe Aiello from Agape was all over it. HUGE help. Ended up saving our bacon as the repairs cost over 15k and the insurance Joe connected us with covered 100% of it. Very pleased. We plan on sticking with Agape for the long-term. I recommend yall check it out and let Joe demolish your current insurance plan. -Caleb
David Calvert
My agent at Agape has always been proactive in making sure we have the best prices on our home and auto, and he has been very reactive in the few times we've had to reach out for either policy. Highly recommended
Theresa Martucci
I cannot say enough about Joe and his Team. When we moved from New York seven years ago we did not know anything about our insurance needs in North Carolina. Joe provide us with the guidance and experience one needs when grouping our insurance. Now my entire family and friends have Joe as their insurance broker
Thanks Joe and good luck
Matthew
Crystal Cannata
Joe helped me with not only personal policies but also business insurance. He is a genuine resource that gives full attention and details and helps you make the best decision for you. He is 100% focused on building lasting relationships with excellent customer care.
Charles Wood
Joe and his team put up with me even though I'm probably one of the most absent minded customers on the planet.
I never think about my insurance these days and it takes a huge load off of my shoulders. I would highly recommend!
Shiloh Turner
Joe and his team helped me get homeowners insurance on my first house. He was very thorough and explained the pros and cons of the insurance policy options while also showing me ways to save money. He was very kind and knowledgeable. I enjoyed working with this team.
Alfreda Rhodes
This group is easy to work with. Everyone I've communicated with are friendly and knowledgeable. Anytime I need something, they are readily available to help. I would recommend Agape Insurance Group to anyone shopping around for insurance.
Mike Allen
Joe was great helping me get my home and liability policies in place after my old company dropped me due to multiple claims. He has great communication and a very calming demeanor.
Candace
I’ve been with Agape for just over a year now. This past renewal I had more changes than anyone to make with my policy and Judith helped me every step of the way. It’s wonderful having a agency who answers the phone and takes time to make sure their customers are in the best hands. If your looking for a new insurance group don’t hesitate on contacting Agape to make sure your getting the best deal and the most help.
Ved Naithani
Very prompt and reliable service.
Heather Abruzzino
I have been with Agape and Joe Aiello for many years and he is such a pleasure to work with. He always knows how to help me, is very quick in getting things done and goes above and beyond. I hope others allow him to help with their insurance needs.
Guido Gabbrielli
Joe Aiello and his team consistently provide outstanding service that goes above and beyond expectations. I’ve been a client for several years, and I am always impressed by their professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail. Joe offers sound, thoughtful recommendations tailored to my specific needs, giving me confidence and peace of mind. Whether it’s a simple policy update or a complex coverage question, I know I can count on Joe and his team to provide clear, reliable guidance. Highly recommend them for anyone looking for a trusted, knowledgeable insurance partner
Michael Bell
Joe will take care of you. Very professional and personable. Thanks Joe
Niki Thompson
I have had the pleasure of working with Adam Behr who has been patient, very professional and a joy to work with. Adam was able to find me auto insurance MUCH lower than what I was currently paying...whew what a relief!!!! So if you're looking to work with Agape, I would highly recommend them and you will be in great hands (sorry Allstate) lol. I will also be sending referrals to Agape. THANK YOU AGAIN ADAM!!!!
Ronald Jennings
The team at Agape has been phenomenal for all my insurance needs. I know I can reach out to Adam and team any time and I’ll be taken care of. Highly recommended!
Jason Boggs
I've trusted Joe and Judith at Agape with my personal and business insurance needs for several years now. Every encounter has been above and beyond traditional customer service. Returned calls with detailed answers and explanations I can understand in common terms and easily act on.
Barzie Drewry
These guys are great when it comes to Business insurance.
They have helped evaluate my business to make sure I have proper coverage in case the worst scenario. I have been using this agency for many years and if you need somebody to back you up, these are the guys.
Brett Webster
Highly recommend!
Angela Benton
I worked with Adam. He is fantastic! He took time to ask me questions about what I needed and didn’t rush into the first option. I felt like he heard me and cared that I was getting the best service for my money. He also was very easy to get ahold of when I had other questions after the fact. Very people focused! This is a great outfit! They take the time to get things right!
Dylan Willis
Joe is very professional, highly recommend giving them a call!
Linwood Koonce
Agape Insurance is one of the best services we have received in a long time. Very professional and friendly.
LD Con
Joe was very professional and helpful. He got me quotes right away that were comprehensive and affordable. I helped to ensure that we were ready to close on our new home on time.
David Wilkie
Joe and Judith at Agape are the absolute best! Always there for you. I highly recommend.
Robert Rossi
We have been customers for almost a year and we are very pleased with the service and the amount of good informative correspondences that we receive. It was a very good transition from our previous insurance carrier to here. Looking forward to another good year.
Jane Roberts
The Agape group was so understanding and provided me with a homeowners policy that surpass my previous policy. The were professional and offered me several options.
Maritza Zavala
Excelent service, I was well informed on services available that better fits my needs. I received excellent follow up, the kind of support that makes you feel you are in trusted hands with Joe Aiello, who is taking good care of your request. Thank you!
suresh nm
I am with Agape (Joe Aiello) last 5 years and I am very much happy with their support and service. They will take care of insurance services for both Home and Auto insurance starting from getting best competitive price and its renewal process every year. Moving forward I will keep continuing with them as I am comfortable with their service.
Raymond McLaughlin
Joe and his team are always very helpful, friendly and professional. I highly recommend him for all your insurance needs. He will always be 100% honest with you.
John Honey
Joe and Judith are both incredibly responsive and consistently take the time to talk through policy options and pricing whenever we have questions.
Debbie Kaiser
We have been using Joe for many years for our home and auto insurance. I was turning 65 in 2024 and worrying about Medicare. Joe reached out to me in 2023 to let me know he could assist with Medicare decisions...and he explained my options and made it so easy. This year my husband needed that same help, got it and also was able to make the best decisions for his health insurance. We are so pleased with Joe and everyone at Agape and are so thankful fir their care and concern.
Lawrence Horton
Joe has always kept us updated on any changes in the insurance industry and keeps reminding us if we have had any changes in our situation that could affect our coverage. Thanks Joe for everything.
Robert Sherman
So I just met with Joe and he was wonderful. Very knowledgeable and answered all my questions. I highly recommend him!
Jacky Philpotts
Joe and his team are always very helpful, professional and get back to me in a timely manner, whether for auto, home or health insurance questions or claims. I highly recommend them for all insurance needs.
Debra Penne
Joe and his team are exceptional. Joe personally has spent a great deal of time explaining a lot about both health and homeowners insurance to me. He has been a wonderful resource for my real-estate clients as well. Can't say enough about their dedication to their work.
Berenice Martinez
I couldn’t be happier with the exceptional service provided by Agape Insurance Group! The team is always professional, friendly, and quick to address any questions or concerns. They take the time to understand my needs and consistently find the best coverage options for both my car and home insurance. Their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction truly set them apart. Highly recommend this agency to anyone looking for reliable and personalized insurance solutions!
Venessa Maldonado
Best insurance company ever!!! They’re all so helpful ❤️
Lauren Egleston
Great group, great insurance. Unfortunately I had to file a homeowners claim this year, but fortunately Agape made this process as smooth as possible. Judith was incredibly helpful during my time of need. Highly recommend this group.
Allen Medlin
Very helpful, nice, easy to deal with.
Patty Sopko
I wanted a change to my policy so ai sent an email. Within minutes I received an email and phone call explaining the change and it was done in a couple of minutes.
Kirk McWhorter
Joe and his team have helped me with insurance policies for my home, car and business. They are first class in everything they do - honest, responsive and always advocating for their customers. I'd highly recommend doing business with Agape.
Cathi Rohrer
Outstanding customer service!
Lindsey Nicole
Extremely professional and helpful. Not only will they help you with small issues like forgetting your username to your account. They’ll keep in contact with you about important details with your account. Very informative and patient when you ask questions.
Kathyann Carmona
They worked very quickly to get me a quote, answered all my questions, and saved me almost $90 a month on auto insurance. I totally recommend Agape Insurance.
Justin Sherwood
I have really enjoyed our experience with Agape Insurance Group! Joe and Judith are a pleasure to work with when it comes to all of our insurance needs. Their availability and attention to detail give me peace of mind knowing I can rely on them!
Cris H.
Wonderful personalized service. I have been with them for over five years and have no complaints. Joe and his team have been nothing but exemplary and wonderful to work with.
Brian Powell
Agape Insurance Group LLC was recommended to me by a friend and customer. He told me how pleased he was with their services and highly recommended them. I took his recommendation and never looked back.
JoAnn Clement
agape insurance group was there for me when my husband went to heaven. Judith was patient and kind with me, a new widow, who didn't know how to do anything! our daughters now are also with agape insurance! I would recommend them to everyone!!!
Marianne Setter
Extremely helpful and responsive to any and all questions and concerns.
HANNAH Barringer
Joe and his team are caring and proactively informative! You always know clearly what to expect with a claim and how to resolve an issue.
Lauren Moock
Joe is wonderful. He and his team are responsive and spend the time explaining things.
RyanCari Sche
I wanted to write this review to express my sincere appreciation and satisfaction with the services provided by Agape Insurance Group. As a client of the agency, I have consistently been impressed with the professionalism, knowledge, and care demonstrated by Joe.
From the very beginning (many years ago), Agape Insurance Group made the process of finding the right insurance coverage for my needs smooth and hassle-free. Joe always took the time to thoroughly explain the options available and helped me choose the best policies to ensure my insurance for both personal and buisiness (home, car, life) were properly covered. Even when insurance companies chance, which they ofter do, Joe has always been on top of it to make sure I understand and see if I was ok with the changes, which in many cases it included an increase of premium. I had dealt with other insurance agencies, and once you are a customer, you hear nothing from them...because you are now on your own. This has never been the case with Agape!!!
Another thing is what sets Agape Insurance Group apart is their commitment to customer service. They are always responsive to my questions and provide clear, detailed answers. Whenever I've needed assistance or had concerns, they have gone above and beyond to address them in a timely and thoughtful manner. Their attention to detail and genuine desire to help is truly evident.
In addition to their excellent service, the agency consistently offers competitive pricing and a range of policy options that fit my budget and needs. I appreciate the transparency and integrity they bring to every interaction.
I wholeheartedly recommend Agape Insurance Group to anyone in need of reliable and trustworthy insurance services. My experience has been nothing short of outstanding, and I look forward to continuing to work with them for all my future insurance needs.
Thank you, Agape Insurance Group, for your exceptional service!
Alyssa Swain
Joe Aiello is very knowledgeable and friendly. He is always looking out for our best interests.
Kristyn Simpson
Adam Behr was an absolute GEM! He helped walk me through properly switching my insurance, and he took time to breakdown my quote when I got confused. If you’re looking for an agent who is patient and knowledgeable, he’s your guy! I’m glad I made the switch to Agape.
Cecilia Williams
What a great insurance experience! From the quote to the payment, I was so impressed. And I saved money!
Brittany Davis
Great experience with Agape the past six years. Joe has always made everything easy for us and is always quick to respond with any questions we've had. Erie has been amazing when we've had to file auto / home claims. Highly recommend Agape for all of your insurance needs!
Aaron Sahm
Great experience for a first time homebuyer!
Seth Spencer
I very much appreciate their tremendous help and patience in finding an excellent insurance plan and helping me navigate my claim after an accident.
janet alford
Joe gave a clear and thorough comparison of my former insurance and what he could offer through Erie. I now have better coverage at a substantial savings. He’s thorough, prompt and great to work with. I highly recommend
Kelly Tarkenton
Joe has a wealth of insurance knowledge. He makes a very complex topic easy to understand so you can make the best choice for you and your family. The process is simple. Joe and crew are easily accessible any time you need them. It is an absolute pleasure and refreshing to work with someone who truly cares.
Michael Nessell
I was involved in an accident. Agape Insurance was very involved and helpful. Answering all of my questions and returned calls and messages promptly.
Tom S
I required a home roof shingle replacement and the Erie Insurance Agape group agency and adjuster handled the claim very well, communication and action, between myself and the contractor.
I would definitely recommend the AGAPE agency.
Tonya Dobish
Erie Insurance was great, I called and talked to someone. They walked me through the process step by step. I haven't had to file a claim in a long time so it was quite a surprise when I called Erie directly they were so helpful to take care of everything. Would highly recommend Erie Insurance
Tony Romain
Worked with Adam Behr on getting some updated homeowners and auto insurance, and not only was he super helpful and courteous, but so timely as well. After playing phone tag with a different agency for weeks, Adam got back to me immediately and we got everything going in just a day or two. I waited longer than that for email replies from the other guys! 10/10 would recommend!
Kathleen Pickens
Great customer service and communication. Very knowledgeable and current regarding market trends. Agape is always available to assist with my insurance needs.
Greg Dawes
Joe Aiello was knowledgeable, very helpful, and quick in terms of the transition from our former insurance to Agape. He made it easy to follow the necessary steps and send him the relevant documentation.
Sam Miller
Excellent service and lower costs.
jorgia vandeventer
Always helpful and great service too!
Rick Messemer, CSA
Have known Joe for several years and has always been knowledgeable, responsive and honest. Has always gone the "extra mile" to research questions we've posed.
Jill Backus
Joe was wonderful, very resposive and made sure coverage was the highest we could get for the best price, highly recommend!
Tiffany Cole Candioti
Joe and Josh at Agape Insurance have been so helpful in finding affordable auto and homeowners insurance! They are friendly, understanding and responsive. I highly recommend working with them.